Robin Gale-Baker, from Sustainable Macleod, discusses mulch. She has also written articles for this website about growing broad beans, cauliflower, eggplants and capsicums, garlic, other vegetables, apricot trees, blueberries, medlar trees, persimmon trees, other fruit trees and herbs. Also articles on growing techniques, shade cloth and the emergency kitchen garden.
With the drought has come high prices for organic mulch, that indispensable item for the home gardener. Pea straw and sugar cane mulch have risen steadily over the past few years and are now the most expensive they have ever been. What are we to do?
Mulch is important for several reasons. Most importantly, it stops the soil surface drying out and retains moisture in the soil. It also prevents weeds growing and seed germinating, and adds organic material to the soil, improving its health and aeration. It insulates the soil, keeping the soil temperature consistent. And it prevents compaction caused by heavy rain.
There are many materials that can be used for mulching. Some are suitable for the veggie garden which generally needs a pH of 6-7, some for trees, and some for acid-loving plants requiring a pH of 5.5 or below:
- Pea straw is high in nitrogen, significantly improves soil microbiology and provides excellent worm food. Spread it 4-10cm deep on new beds and 2-4cm if refreshing beds previously mulched.
- Sugar cane mulch has a low pH and should be mixed with some dolomite to balance it. It is quite fine and can mat, providing a bedding for creeping weeds such as chickweed but, as it breaks down rapidly, it does benefit the soil microbiology quickly. It is more expensive in the long run than pea straw because of its rapid decomposition. Spread it to a depth of between 4-10cm.
- Fruit trees do well with wood chip. At this time of year, pull back any mulch to the dripline of the tree and ring the dripline with 6-8cm width and height of woodchip. This encourages fungi, plus worms which take the mulch underground and shred it, thus creating a soil food web.
- Acid-loving plants, such as blueberries and passionfruit, require an acid mulch. Pine needles when aged are suitable but, when unaged, contain terpenes, which are chemicals that are toxic to many plants. Cedar chips also contain these.
- Kelp seaweed is my favourite mulch but unfortunately is almost impossible to get, and it is illegal to collect it from beaches. It provides sodium, boron (which soils in our area are deficient in) and other trace elements plus nitrogen and potash.
- Growing a green manure crop is a cheap and quick form of mulching. Once matured, cut the plants at ground level and spread them. Leave the roots in and they will provide runnels for water to enter the soil.
Other readily available mulches – often free – include grass clippings, leaves and coffee grounds and husks. All must be applied very lightly as they can mat and also produce an unpleasant odour.
- Grass, which will add nitrogen as it breaks down, should be dried and spread thinly. Avoid grass clippings with dog faeces and lawns that have been sprayed with pesticides to kill weeds. As a green material, grass clippings will support soil bacteria.
- Leaves break down slowly and, to prevent matting, they need to be spread very thinly. If green, they support bacteria; if brown, fungi.
- Coffee husks by themselves are a disaster turning into a heavy, rancorous mat but with coffee grounds rubbed through them by hand – a somewhat tedious job – they are usable and will improve the soil.
- Wood shavings and sawdust rob the soil of nitrogen (good for keeping paths weed free for that reason) and should be avoided, though they can be added to the compost bay.
Macleod Organic Community Garden has free wood chip mulch from Banyule City Council. Turn up at the garden with bags, tubs or trailers on Wednesdays or Saturdays between 1pm and 4pm and take as much as you like. Bring a fork or spade!
After this article was published, several people wrote in:
Carol Woolcock: “I grow green manure crops using packets of McKenzies legumes (whole green peas, any of the beans and chickpeas) from the supermarket. Very cheap ($1.80 for 375 grams) compared to the small packets of seeds from nurseries ($4.25 for 30 seeds).”
Fay Loveland: “I would like to suggest the use of newspaper as a way to keep garden beds moist. Over the last three months, I have been trialling a no dig garden method developed by permaculturist Morag Gamble and I’m very happy with the results. In this method, layers of wet newspaper are added under the final mulch layer. By having the newspaper as the last layer before the mulch, rather than laid on the ground under the compost layer: the compost layer integrates more rapidly with the existing soil; soil flora and fauna quickly get to work without the barrier in between; the compost layer stays a more moist and stable temperature under the paper layer; the newspaper layer prevents weeds from growing in your garden, including the unwanted seeds from your compost; less nutrients from the compost are evaporated and lost; and the roots of plants can penetrate directly into the soil so stay hydrated longer, can access minerals and have increased resilience and stability.”
Kay Wawn: “I owned Urban Farming permaculture business for 11 years, now closed, and sold mulch + other natural fertilisers, etc so can tell you:
- There are 30 types of straw and pea straw is the best for mulch on veggies and fruit trees as it retains the moisture and releases nitrogen, It lasts around 8-10 months.
- Apart from only needing to water every few days in the summer, another benefit of pea straw is that when it breaks down it improves the soil. Plus it is attractive to worms as soon as it is put down as the top layer on the soil.
- Tip: break up the pea straw bales and immerse in a tub of water of water next to where you are working, then throw it on. Because it is wet, it holds together better and does not blow away.
- A few of the peas do shoot. However, these contribute to addition of nitrogen plus they can be eaten (peas in pod).
- Fava bean is thicker/coarser than pea straw and, as a consequence, lasts longer but it is nowhere near as efficient for water retention nor does it have as much nitrogen as the pea straw. I use it on the nature strip in Preston on natives for weed suppression.
- Mushroom compost is high in pH and is therefore not suitable for all plants. It is better mixed with compost to break it down in a layer beneath the pea straw.”
Rice hulls as mulch
A lively discussion about rice hulls as mulch also took place:
Gerard Maloney: “I use rice hulls as a mulch. I can buy a 125kg bag for $55 at a local produce store and they last for years as a mulch and do not mat.”
Julie French: “I recently visited a farm in Bali where they use rice hulls in their vegetable gardens. The hulls are first burnt, or scorched (see photo), left for 6 months, then mixed into their composting system. They are blessed with rich volcanic soils and plenty of rain but still need to constantly renew the soils that they grow with.”
Heather: “I’ve been using rice hulls for years and found them very good for keeping nests and floors dry … plus the chooks can nibble them for extra fibre.”
Jaime Edge: “I would love to be able to buy rice hulls (to use in my chicken coop, we have used this method for years with great success) but I can’t find a supplier with stock.”
Rebecca Parsons: “St Andrews Stock Feed currently have large bales of rice hulls in stock. $85 for 125Kg.”
A number of other local stock feed suppliers are willing to order the bales for you. However, the manufacturer Coprice is not currently making them. Their response to our enquiry: “Unfortunately no, we do not have rice hulls at present. The shortage will be for the 2020 cropping year (April through to March 2020) due to the drought and shortage of rice crops. When we start to get rain and water, this will hopefully change in 2020.“